Bangladesh students demand abolition of job quota system
Thousands of students launch a fresh movement as government fails to honour its promise to end quota in government jobs.
Thousands of university students in Bangladesh are boycotting classes as part of a nationwide protest, with demonstrators blocking the main thoroughfare in the capital, Dhaka, on Monday, calling for abolition of quota system in government jobs.
The latest protest comes a month after Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina announced to "abolish" the country's decades-old quota system in the recruitment civil servants.
Muhammad Rashed Khan, joint convener of "Council to Protect Bangladesh's General Students Rights" told Al Jazeera that they had been holding a peaceful movement since the announcement made by the prime minister.
"Thirty-two days have passed, but no gazette notification in this regard has been published yet. We have no option but to be on the streets again," said Khan.
He led a procession of around 3,000 protestors at Dhaka University on Monday, suspending all classes and tutorials.
At Chittagong University, about 1,000 protesting students have been staging a sit-in on the rail tracks. No train has left the port city for the campus since morning.
"Unless a gazette notification is issued about quota abolishment, we will not leave streets and will launch a tougher movement," said Khan.
Under the quota system, 56 percent of the nearly 3,000 government positions are filled through annual examination under various quotas, leaving the remaining 44 percent for general category students.
About 50,000 students from all 38 public universities and around 50 of the 96 private universities protested for three straight days in April forcing Prime Minister Hasina to promise abolition of the quota system.
On May 8, a day after the deadline set by students, Cabinet Secretary Mohammad Shafiul Alam said, "There's no progress in cancelling quota system."
The announcement has re-ignited the protest again. On May 9, students at Dhaka University held a 1,200 strong human chain, and set May 11 as the new deadline to issue gazette notification.
Cabinet Secretary Alam meanwhile, told the media on Monday noon that the paperwork on this issue has been forwarded to the Prime Minister’s Office. “The issue of quota is under process; a decision will be made soon," he said.
Since February, students have been agitating to demand that the quota be reduced from the current 56 percent to 10 percent.
They say this would create a level-playing field while also protecting the rights of candidates from minority sections, who get the benefit of the quota system.
The movement was initially led by students of Dhaka University in the capital, but spread to other universities across the country.
Abir Raihan had participated in April protests in Dhaka braving tear-gas and rubber bullets from police, only to find himself there again this Monday for the same cause.
"The prime minister herself declared there will be no quota in government jobs; why there is no gazette notification on that till now?" asked Raihan, a third year student of Dhaka University.
A legacy of the colonial British rulers, competitive exams to recruit government officials are prevalent across the sub-continent, including India and Pakistan. After its liberation from Pakistan in 1971, Bangladesh formed its own Public Service Commission, which has been conducting the Bangladesh Civil Service exam to recruit civil servants since 1972.
Each year, a little over half of the 220,000-odd university graduates in Bangladesh take this examination and compete for 2,400 to 3,000 posts in various government offices, which are considered among the most "prestigious and lucrative" jobs in the country.
Of the 56 percent reserved positions, the biggest quota, 30 percent, is for the children and grandchildren of freedom fighters while 10 percent is for women and another 10 percent is reserved for people from backward districts, while members of indigenous communities get five percent quota. The physically challenged people get the remaining one percent.
The student movement, which started off with peaceful protests near Dhaka University in mid-February, took on a more organised form with the help of social media campaigns.
This had the desired effect. On April 9, a large crowd of students occupied Shahbagh intersection in Dhaka, disrupting traffic across the capital city. The protest escalated as the police used teargas and rubber bullets against the students, leaving over 100 of them injured.
News of the police action spread through the media and on social media. By noon of April 10, the protests spread across the country, with students in the major cities, including Chittagong, Khulna, Rajshahi, Barisal, Rangpur, Sylhet and Savar boycotting classes in solidarity with the protestors.
Prime Minister Hasina was forced to concede to the demands. "There is no need for quota system in the public service," she told parliament on April 11.
"Go back home. As you don't want it, the quota system will be scrapped."
What's wrong with quota system?
Bangladesh has one of the highest "graduate unemployment rates" in the South Asia region. According to a 2014 report by the Economist Intelligence Unit, five out of every 10 graduates are unemployed (compared to three out of 10 in India and Pakistan).
According to a World Bank report, the pace of job creation has fallen in recent years: between 2003 and 2010, the total employment grew by 3.1 percent per annum, which fell down to 1.8 percent per annum between 2011 to 2016.
Despite the high unemployment rate, posts in government offices often remain vacant as a result of the government’s inability to find suitable candidates under the various quotas.
In January, Public Administration Minister Syed Ashraful Islam told parliament that over 350,000 posts in various ministries and government divisions remained vacant.
Data maintained by his ministry put the number of approved posts of government jobs at 17,10,704 and of incumbents at 13,51,704.
Under these circumstance, the student protests for quota reforms are reasonable and justified, said Dr Musleh Uddin Ahmed, professor in the Department of Public Administration at Dhaka University.
He said most of these vacant posts could have been filled if a "large number of civil servants were recruited based on merit instead of the quota".
Ahmed was also critical of the 30 percent quota for children and grandchildren of freedom fighters.
Giving grounds for such criticism, the Public Service Commission's data reveals that in the 31st, 32nd and 33rd Bangladesh Civil Service exams (between 2012 to 2014), 63 percent, 37 percent and 84 percent of posts respectively under the freedom fighter quota remained vacant.
The vacancies may have something to do with the fact that since the 1971 war, the freedom fighters' list in Bangladesh has been changed six times under various governments.
Commentators say that with the process of listing freedom fighters lacking transparency, the list has become questionable. There have also been instances when the freedom fighter certificates of high-ranking government officials have turned out to be false upon verification.
"Freedom fighters are the best sons and daughters of our country and I think their debt is unpayable," said Ahmed.
"But after 47 years of independence, reserving seats in a merit-based public service examination for the children of freedom fighters doesn’t make much sense. There are many other ways to honour our freedom fighters," he added.
Former cabinet secretary Dr Akbar Ali Khan told Al Jazeera that preparing for a competitive exam like the Bangladesh Civil Service examination requires considerable time and labour.
"There are many meritorious students who now feel reluctant in even preparing for the exam as they believe fighting for less than half of the seats in the examination is not worthwhile," he said.
"Some portion of quota, however, should be kept for the ethnic minorities, otherwise their right to equal opportunity will not be ensured," Khan said.